blob: b3b622a3a4d09286c0664aa0336fcfa96543ed08 [file] [log] [blame]
---
date: 2015-01
fledgling:
- samoa
- Corinthia
- Kylin
- NiFi
- taverna
- zepplin
growth-issues:
- Aurora
- Brooklyn
- Calcite
- MRQL
- odftoolkit
- parquet
- ranger
- usergrid
infrastructure:
ip-clearance:
- "Corinthia initial source grant"
ipmc:
entering:
- hyunsik
leaving:
- srowen
- marvin
legal-trademarks:
miscellaneous:
- |
NPanday community seems to be in agreement that retirement is the best
option at this point. The only outstanding issue before formally
recommending graduation VOTE is to decide whether there's enough cycles
available for one last release before retirement.
no-release:
- DataFu
- HTrace
- Ignite
- Kalumet
- Lens
- tamaya
no-report:
- NPanday
- ripple
podlings:
count: 36
graduating:
- samza
new:
- Corinthia
- zeppelin
releases:
Brooklyn:
-
date: 2014-12-22
release: 0.7.0-M2-incubating
falcon:
-
date: 2014-12-05
release: 0.6-incubating
samza:
-
date: 2014-12-08
release: 0.8.0-incubating
reports:
Aurora:
board-issues:
community-development: |
Latest Additions:
* PMC addition:
* David McLaughlin, 2014-08-20
* Contributor additions: No additional contributors had code committed
since the last report, however three new contributors currently have
code under review that was submitted within the past 6 weeks. At least
one of these contributions is a large feature addition, which is
promising.
Issue backlog status since last report (Oct 1, 2014):
* Created: 212
* Resolved: 177
Mailing list activity since last report:
* @dev 480 messages
* @issues 1085 messages
* @reviews 2235 messages
graduation-issues:
- "Expanding the community's diversity and adding new committers"
- "Third Apache release, progress being tracked in ticket AURORA-872"
project-development: |
* Increased participation from new contributors within the Aurora core and
ecosystem, for example a Chef cookbook and Docker support under
development.
* Continued to hold weekly IRC meetings, digests sent to dev@ list
* Large improvements to project documentation and website.
committers:
count: 14
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
count: 14
entering:
dmclaughlin: 2014-08-20
leaving:
signoff:
jfarrell: true
benh: false
mattmann: true
hsaputra: true
notes:
ptgoetz: |
Podling looks very healthy. 3 of 4 mentors engaged since last report.
Brooklyn:
board-issues:
community-development: |
Our community continues to grow slowly but surely, and has received
interest and contributions from new community members.
We had the opportunity to talk about our project at ApacheCon Europe
recently, which has introduced Brooklyn to a wider audience within
Apache.
graduation-issues:
- "Grow the community"
- "More diversity of the committers/PPMC (currently biased towards employees of a single organization)"
- "Following up our first release with further, regular, releases"
project-development: |
Code continues to be proposed and merged at a high rate. We are
satisfied with our technical velocity.
We recently completed our first release as an Apache project, and
look forward to following this up with regular releases from now on.
committers:
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
hogstrom: false
akarasulu: false
ke4qqq: true
marrs: false
jbonofre: true
olamy: false
chipchilders: true
asavu: false
jzb: true
jim: true
notes:
chipchilders: |
The Brooklyn community is doing very well in learning the rules /
policies / nuances of working at the ASF. It still needs a bit more time
to build up a diverse community IMO, but things are looking good.
ke4qqq: |
The Brooklyn folks kicked out their first release during this reporting
cycle, which is an important milestone. Work still remains in terms of
building a diverse community.
Calcite:
board-issues:
community-development: |
In December, there were 84 messages on dev@, 45 commits, 50 issues
created, 27 issues resolved by 7 contributors.
Julian Hyde gave a talk "SQL on everything, in memory" about Calcite
at the Strata + Hadoop World conference in October, and held an
"office hour" with interested community members. He also spoke at
a Hive meet-up in New York and a Kylin meet-up in San Jose about
how those projects integrate with Calcite.
Collaborations are under way with other Apache projects: with Drill
to make implementation convention more neutral; with Hive for join
algorithm selection, and leveraging sorted data; and with Phoenix
to create a Calcite adapter for Phoenix.
graduation-issues:
- "Continue to build community"
- "Add more committers and PPMC members"
- "Demonstrate community robustness by rotating project tasks among multiple project members"
project-development: |
We have completed the rename from Optiq to Calcite. We have also
re-organized the code into the org.apache.calcite namespace. We are
planning to make a 1.0 release in January with the re-organized
code.
committers:
count: 5
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
tdunning: true
gates: true
stevenn: true
notes:
Corinthia:
board-issues:
community-development: |
This is our first podling report.
We have spend a lot of mail on getting acquainted and finding the strength
of each other.
Now discussion are flowing freely. We have consensus on PPMC == Committer
as long as we are in incubator.
graduation-issues:
- "complete the move to ASF infrastructure"
- "Discuss and decide on a medium-term roadmap"
- "Grow the community"
project-development: |
This is our first podling report.
We are at work making a stable kernel so we can more easily add more
developers.
committers:
count: 8
entering:
pescetti: 2014-12-31
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
pescetti: 2014-12-31
leaving:
signoff:
humbedooh: true
jani: true
notes:
DataFu:
board-issues: |
1. Has not yet made a release, but is in process of preparing first.
2. Need to dramatically grow the contributor base.
community-development: |
New committer and PMC member. Several JIRAs filed by new users.
graduation-issues:
- "Grow user and contributor base."
- "Make first release."
- "Increase activity for initial committers."
project-development: |
1. 16 issues created, several from new contributors.
2. 8 issues closed.
3. Reasonable amount of mailing list traffic.
committers:
count: 16
entering:
rjurney: 2014-11
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
rjurney: 2014-11
leaving:
signoff:
hashutosh: false
rvs: true
tdunning: true
notes:
HTrace:
board-issues:
community-development: |
* 141 messages on dev@htrace
* 42 issues resolved and 11 open
graduation-issues:
- "Make our first release from incubator"
- "Move dependent projects over to the incubator version"
- "Continue to grow user and contributor base; i.e. grow the community."
project-development: |
* This is our first report.
* We are fully moved over to Apache Infrastructure now (thanks in
particular to Jake Farrell for help here).
* We have our first htrace website published.
* Development of an easy to deploy htraced trace sink and visualization is
moving along nicely.
* An htrace receiver for Apache Flume was contributed.
* We have put up 5 release candidates for our 1st podling release with a
6th on its way.
committers:
count: 12
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
jfarrell: true
todd: false
lewismc: true
apurtell: false
billie: true
stack: true
notes:
johndament: |
The podling is working through its first release slowly. First release
is always the hardest. Good activity for a new podling on the lists,
still waiting on the board report though.
Ignite:
board-issues:
community-development: |
Several contributors expressed interest in contributing.
graduation-issues:
- "Finish migration to Apache process."
- "Grow active and healthy community around Apache Ignite product."
- "Get on a stable release schedule and have 3 successful product releases."
project-development: |
- Started the implementation of JCache (JSR 107) specification.
- Integrated JCache (JSR 107) TCK test suite into project lifecycle.
- Made significant improvements to Apache Ignite (incubating) website.
- Submitted SGA from GridGain to Apache Ignite (incubating) for In-Memory
Hadoop Accelerator.
committers:
count: 15
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
brane: true
cos: true
hsaputra: true
rvs: true
stack: true
notes:
adc: |
This podling is off to a great start. Mentors are extremely active
participants with most of the non-Jira chatter being between Dmitriy
Setrakyan and the mentors; look to the Jira issue to see the rest of the
community "getting it done". The "issues to be addressed" section seems
reasonable.
brane: |
I agree with Alan's assessment, but I'd really like to see more
activity on the dev@ list; especially more of the initial committers
getting involved in discussions there. Whilst Jira notifications are
nice, I have a nagging feeling that most of the discussions within
the community are happening off-line, which leaves a rather large
hole in the community's collective memory (i.e., mail archives).
This will have to be addressed before graduation.
Kalumet:
board-issues:
community-development: |
Apache Kalumet 0.6-incubating version has been released. However, due to
some misunderstanding, the release vote has not been completed by 3 IPMC.
Especially, some legal files issues have been raised.
We are preparing a 0.6.1-incubating release to fix the legal files and
submit to IPMC vote.
We are in the way of promoting the documentation on the website.
graduation-issues:
project-development: |
We are preparing the 0.6.1-incubating (plan for December, 27) to fix the
legal files issues raised on 0.6-incubating release and have a complete
IPMC vote.
We are preparing the 0.7-incubating release with the development changes.
A new contributor has been identified and started to work on some issues
and refactoring of the webconsole (mockup provided using Vaadin).
Local branches have been created containing:
- new model and REST API
- new webconsole (remove of Echo framework)
These local branches will be merged on the 0.7-incubating branch (master).
Before Graduation:
- The documentation has been updated and aligned with the 0.6-incubating
release. The documentation will be promoted on the website and "linked"
in announcement e-mails as soon as the 0.6.1-incubating release has been
voted.
- The 0.7-incubating release will fix the graduation issue, especially in
term of license (removal of Echo2 framework for the UI).
Post Graduation:
- Kalumet scripts. It's the extension of the "software" concept globally
to all Kalumet resources. It will allow users to create custom
deployment/update plan, with a set of fine-grained steps.
committers:
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
jim: true
hgomez: false
jbonofre: true
olamy: false
notes:
Kylin:
board-issues:
community-development: |
The community is growing. Several new members have started actively
contributing to the project. New contributors made a significant
contribution in develop new feature, fix bugs, refine web experience. The
Kylin meetups at Bay Area and Beijing was well attended. Apache Kylin has
been presented at Big Data Technology Conference 2014, Beijing which is
one of biggest Big Data conference in China. Interest of people during
that event was great and engaged a lots of organizations and individuals,
many of them started to evaluate and joined Kylin community.
graduation-issues:
- "Migrate source code and issue tracking from github.com to Apache Git and JIRA"
- "Make the first release from apache"
- "Make project website available on apache"
project-development: |
1. The project setup is going quite well. Initial committers are
onboarding, JIRA, mailing list were successfully done, Web content has
been migrated to Apache Git but need tuning. Main source code migration
will be done in January 2015.
2. Bug fixing, enhancement are happing on current branch which
will be the target v1.0 release.
3. Work toward next gen version (supports inverted-index) is
progressing substantially.
committers:
count: 11
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
omalley: true
tdunning: true
hsaputra: true
notes:
Lens:
board-issues: |
We are still waiting for project website creation via
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-8549
community-development: |
* Logo of the project has been finalized and published.
* Added one new committer/PPMC - Rajat Khandelwal
* Had contributor meetup in Bangalore, India
* Mailing list subscription (as on 2015-jan-03):
* Dev list: 29 members
* Commits list: 14 members
* User list: 21 members
graduation-issues:
- "Make the first release from apache"
- "Make project website available on apache"
- "Reach out to people through presentations and blogs"
project-development: |
* Main activities include
* Podling setup wrt jenkins and pushing docs
* Improving documentation
* Stabilizing the code for first stable release
* Feature additions - Join chains in OLAP cube
* Mailing list activity :
* Dev via mail-archives.apache.org:
* December - 1380 messsages
* Commits via mail-archives.apache.org:
* December - 50 messages
* User mailing list activity - None
* Issues 101 created and 62 resolved (via 30 day summary from LENS Jira)
committers:
count: 14
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
cdouglas: true
jghoman: true
jbonofre: true
notes:
adc: |
Very good report; an exemplar of how reports should be done. The
community seems very active and healthy. IMO, only items 1 & 2 are
required for graduation.
MRQL:
board-issues: |
The project is not making much progress on the level of increasing the
number of active committers and expanding the users community.
This is already being discussed inside the project community and the main
active committer asked to give the project more few months as he will try
spreading the word more about the project through some public events
community-development:
graduation-issues:
- "Increase the number of active committers"
- "Increase adoption, expand user community, and increase user list activity"
project-development: |
During the last three month, 12 jira issues were reported, from which 10
were fixed. Most of these issues were related to MRQL query evaluation in
Flink mode. Finally, we have set up MRQL on ASF Jenkins, which is a CI
server that continuously checks the integrity of our builds and validates
our tests.
committers:
count: 12
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
adc: true
akarasulu: false
mnour: true
notes:
cos: |
Very light email list traffic compare to prev. month. Mentors are
active.
NiFi:
board-issues:
community-development: |
The dev mailing list has picked up 20 new e-mails since the last report
and is now at 62 (commits has grown to 25).
At the suggestion of the community we've adopted a review-then-commit
strategy which is designed to among other things help with community
development.
We've received several patches from members outside the initial committer
list including changes which dramatically improved our build process and
provide new extensions.
graduation-issues:
- "Produce an initial release."
- "Grow our community beyond the initial set of committers."
- "Establish rhythm for releases, review processes, and document how to most effectively bring on new committers."
project-development: |
All of our current infrastructure needs are setup and things are working
really well. Our focus now is on working towards our first release which
is 0.0.1 and presently comprised of 85 JIRA issues the vast majority of
which are resolved. We've conducted a thorough review of all source files
to ensure proper license headers/notices/disclaimers are present. We've
completed a thorough review and modification of the overall LICENSE and
NOTICE files in preparation for release. We've conducted the initial
podling name search and submitted the ticket for that analysis to be
verified and confirmed.
committers:
count: 14
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
billie: true
arvind: true
esteve: false
bimargulies: true
brock: true
drew: false
apurtell: true
notes:
tnachen: |
Project is still setting up and in the early phase. Mailing list and commits are fairly active..
NPanday:
board-issues:
community-development:
graduation-issues:
project-development:
committers:
count: 9
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
rbircher: false
cos: false
notes:
ptgoetz: |
NPanday has missed the last two reports (last report August 2014). One
of two mentors are engaged and encouraging the podling to make a final
release before retiring (last release was on 2011-05-17). However, there
is little PPMC/Committer involvement with only 2 PPMC members showing
involvement on the dev@ list in the past year. Also confirmed that a
report reminder email was received by the dev@ list for each of the last
missed reporting periods as well at the current period.
It's clear that mentors past and present have attempted to help the
NPanday project grow to a viable size -- at least enough to approve a
release, new Committer/PPMC Member, or even decide to retire -- without
success.
The main warning signs appear to be:
* Inability to reach community consensus (barely 2 acive Committer/PPMC
Members, making 3 +1s for any vote very difficult)
* Inability to perform releases
* Inability to grow the community to a viable size
The issues listed above do not indicate a lack of mentor involvement,
but rather a community in decline.
odftoolkit:
board-issues:
community-development: |
We have made a release but there has been little activity since then.
We still need to attract more members and publicizing the project in the
ODF.
Our validator was used on the ODF Plugfest, ahead a patch was provided by
a new contributor.
graduation-issues:
- "Grow the community in terms of committers"
- "Have regular releases"
- "Decide if we would like to be a top level project or join an existing project, or move to the attic."
project-development: |
Update of ODF validator before the ODF Plugfest (London).
There have been some user issues reported and responded to.
ODF Toolkit part of presentation on the Apache Con Europe.
committers:
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
billie: true
arvind: true
esteve: false
bimargulies: true
brock: true
drew: false
apurtell: true
notes:
robweir: |
My concern is the same as before. IMHO we've grown too comfortable
being a podling. We're able to do everything we want to do as a
podling, have a website, check in code, make releases, etc. I'm not
really feeling any urgency from committers or PPMC members to push
this project through to the next steps needed for graduation.
Advantages of being a Top Level Project at Apache include:
1) Less process overhead for releasing. We still need to check all
of the items, but we're then trusted to do this on our own without
additional IPMC review.
2) Our releases would no longer have the Incubation disclaimer in the
release notes
3) We'd get a top level URL for the website odf@apache.org, and a
shortened mailing list address, dev@odf.apache.org.
4) We'd have more freedom to do publicity via press releases, etc.
5) We'd still need to do quarterly reports, but these would go
directly to the Apache Board.
Although none of these by themselves are huge, take together it is a
nice bundle of perks. And it really signifies that, as a community,
we understand The Apache Way, the release procedures and are able to
sustain the community.
In our report this month we list the three most important things to do
on the way to graduation:
1. Grow the community in terms of committers
2. Have regular releases
3. Decide if we would like to be a top level project or join an existing
project, or move to the attic.
Any proposals on what we can do for #1 and #2? For example, do we
have any contributed patches we still need to integrate? Are there
other ways we could think of for publicizing the project, and
attracting additional volunteers?
tnachen: |
It seems like the project is active in release and code (towards the low activity side).
However the mailing list traffic and engagement has decreased overtime and the
dev list even with jira notifications is still very low traffic.
parquet:
board-issues:
community-development: |
Latest Additions:
* PMC addition: None
* Contributor addition: Dan Weeks and Alex Levenson
Issue backlog status since last report:
* Created: 45
* Resolved: 20
Mailing list activity since last report:
* dev 310 messages: 90 in Oct, 126 in Nov, and 94 in Dec
graduation-issues:
- "Expanding the community and adding new committers"
- "1st releases toward org.apache Parquet 1.6.0 GA"
- "Identifying how to ensure timely code reviews by committers"
project-development: |
- Completed first release, Apache Parquet Format (incubating) 2.2.0
- Established a by-law for adding committers
- Added 2 new committers
- Parquet presentation accepted for Strata San Jose
committers:
count: 19
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
todd: false
jfarrell: true
mattmann: true
rvs: true
tomwhite: false
notes:
cos: |
Mailing lists are active; most mentors are active.
ranger:
board-issues:
community-development: |
* Added few more contributors
* Vote for adding an additional committer is in progress with
private@ranger.incubator
* Issues (JIRAs) created/resolved since last report (after Oct-01-2014
before Dec-30-2014):
Created: 115
Resolved: 100
graduation-issues:
- "Increase the Ranger contributors/committers across industry verticals"
- "Establish a automated git check-in process to validate the check-in patches for quality control (similar to Hadoop QA)"
- "Add more documentation to support new users and contributors."
project-development: |
* Project Name has been renamed from "Apache Argus” to “Apache Ranger”
* Three Release candidates were voted in dev community for Ranger-0.4.0
version and RC3 has been voted to be released in IPMC
* First release of Apache Ranger 0.4.0 on Nov-17,2014
* Apache Ranger 0.4.0 Release artifacts are published in
official dist directory.
* Ranger Documentation wiki Site
(https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/RANGER) has been added.
* Working on release of Apache 0.4.1 to avoid compilation issues related
to SNAPSHOT libraries in HBase and Hive dependencies
* Working on adding more security functionalities for the next release,
Apache Ranger 0.5.0
committers:
count: 12
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
gates: true
humbedooh: true
ddas: false
jghoman: true
omalley: true
notes:
johndament: |
Ranger suffered a bit from a renaming issue that came up. Activity on
the lists is a little bit lighter since, but I'm sure will bounce back.
I'm concerned over inability to access the wiki though, sent a note to
the podling to request proper access.
ripple:
board-issues:
community-development:
graduation-issues:
project-development:
committers:
count: 11
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
jukka: false
grobmeier: false
asavory: false
samoa:
board-issues:
community-development: |
This is the first report.
graduation-issues:
- "Get IP clearance (SGA) from Yahoo"
- "Move the current code into ASF's git repository"
- "Start working as an Apache project"
project-development: |
This is the first report.
committers:
count: 11
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
gates: false
hashutosh: false
enis: false
tdunning: true
notes:
samza:
board-issues:
community-development: |
Continued growth in mailing list, particularly from new users.
graduation-issues:
project-development: |
Released version 0.8.
committers:
count: 12
entering:
-
cpsoman: 2014-08-13
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
-
cpsoman: 2014-08-13
leaving:
signoff:
cdouglas: true
acmurthy: false
rvs: true
notes:
tamaya:
board-issues: |
There are many discussions about how simple the API and or code should be.
community-development: |
We got a new contributor, Reinhard Sandtner who already shipped a patch
and is participating in some discussions.
graduation-issues:
- "Project web site must be setup (done)."
- "Establish a solid code base for a release."
- "Continue to grow the community."
project-development: |
The project setup is going quite well. The initial code donation is under
ongoing review.
committers:
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
johndament: true
struberg: true
gpetracek: true
dblevins: false
notes:
johndament: |
Podling is struggling a bit with some growing pains. Hope it will
straighten out soon.
taverna:
board-issues:
community-development: |
Quiet month - dominated by migration issues.
Involvement with students who are combining Taverna and Apache Storm.
Email traffic December 2014:
* dev@taverna: 50 messages
* users@taverna: 12 messages
graduation-issues:
- "IP clearance to be signed by Univ of Manchester"
- "Move source code, wiki, issues to apache.org."
- "Re-awake community after migration, prepare a release"
project-development: |
The project is waiting for the Software Grant from Univ of Manchester
Solicitor and Contracts Manager as he needed to retrieve the existing CLAs
from archive. He has replied (2015-01-05): "They should arrive back from
storage this week and we can proceed with the [software grant] transfer"
Taverna's WSDL-support modified to work with Apache Woden.
About 45% of code base ready to be migrated (moved to slimmer git layout,
modified to org.apache.taverna groupId and build).
TODO: LICENSE and NOTICE plugins for Maven.
Apache Taverna website live at
http://taverna.incubator.apache.org/
-- not yet migrating content from
http://www.taverna.org.uk/ until IP clearance sorted
Discussions around packaging / Debian
committers:
count: 16
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
andy: true
mattmann: true
suresh: false
smarru: false
mpierce: true
notes:
andy: |
Given the podling has not yet got the software grant on ASF file,
through no fault of the podling, I suggest keeping reporting Taverna
monthly.
jmclean: |
Off to a good start, with discussions about making builds and assembling
LICENSE and NOTICE. Mentors (very) active.
usergrid:
board-issues:
community-development: |
We added a couple of new committers: Alex Muramoto, Ryan Bridges and John
Ament. We are working on our second release from the Incubator, Usergrid
1.0.1 and are creating release candidates now for voting.
graduation-issues:
- "Continue to build community"
- "Perfect release process"
- "Exclude unnecessary dependencies from release"
project-development: |
Much work has been done in the "two-dot-o" version of Usergrid with a new
persistence and query engine. Bugs have been fixed in the master branch
and it is now being prepared for a Usergrid 1.0.1 release.
committers:
count: 10
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
snoopdave: true
jfarrell: true
jim: true
lewismc: false
lresende: false
notes:
johndament: |
The group is still getting accustomed to the Apache Way. Special thanks
to those in the incubator who have helped with licensing issues in the
current release attempt.
zeppelin:
board-issues:
community-development: |
Zeppelin has just entered the ASF Incubator and the onboarding
is progressing nicely. All initial committers have been issued
ASF accounts and the basic INFRA has been setup.
graduation-issues:
- "Complete the SGA"
- "Migrate to ASF infrastructure"
- "Complete PODLINGNAMESEARCH-64"
project-development: |
This is the first report.
committers:
entering:
leaving:
ppmc:
entering:
leaving:
signoff:
cos: true
hyunsik: true
tdunning: true
hsaputra: true
rvs: true
notes:
shepherds:
Aurora: pgoetz
Brooklyn: smarru
Calcite: mfranklin
Corinthia: rbircher
DataFu: drew
HTrace: johndament
Ignite: adc
Kalumet: wave
Kylin: asavu
Lens: adc
MRQL: cos
NiFi: tnachen
NPanday: pgoetz
odftoolkit: tnachen
parquet: cos
ranger: johndament
ripple: rgardler
samoa: rbircher
samza: mfranklin
tamaya: smarru
taverna: jmclean
usergrid: asavu
summary: |
IPMC has recognized the need for tightening up mentorship requirements
and overall structure of the incubation process. Active discussions
on how to this in the best possible way are on going and the recommendation
is expected to be available in a few weeks.